Woops! Tiffany Outs NKOTB Jonathan Knight!

While New Kids on the Block member Jonathan Knight has never come out officially, the internet (and everyone) has basically assumed that he was gay. It only stands to reason that one member in every boy band is. At least one.

However, last week it seemed that teen pop queen Tiffany let the secret out of the bag while on Bravo’s Watch What Happens: Live. Host Andy Cohen asked Tiffany if she had hooked up with any of the boys back in her days as a touring mall songstress.

“The quiet one, the shy one,” Tiffany admitted. “[Jonathan Knight] became gay later. I didn’t do it. I had issues with that. I was thinking maybe I did. Now looking back when we were dating, he was so much fun. We used to do facials together. He was so easy to talk to.”

No statement from Knight has been released yet regarding Tiffany’s controversial remarks.