The story follows a group of recent high school grads as they live it up one final time at a high school graduation party. The party follows several classmates as they embark on different paths following high school. The heart of the film is the story of Preston Myers (Ethan Embry) who has finally worked up the courage to tell a recently single prom queen, Amanda (Jennifer Love Hewitt), that he has loved her since freshman year. Meanwhile, Amanda is in the search of the author of a love letter addressed to her. The movie also stars a young Peter Facinelli, Seth Green, and features Jason Segal, Melissa Joan Hart and Donald Faison.