An inside source tells Page Six, “Paula was totally fooled. She bought into his character and to this day isn’t aware she was fooled.”
Seriously, though, I wouldn’t brag too much about pulling one over on ol’ Paula. Lord knows I love her, but let’s be real here. It’s as easy as counting to three. Unless you’re Paula, in which case it’s all but impossible without cue cards.
Gallery Info: Paula Abdul meets fans outside of the Koi restaurant.