This is one of the hardest unofficially casting calls I have ever been through. The part of Christian Grey in the sextastic Twilight fan fiction novel, Fifty Shades of Grey is impossible to identify. He’s certainly not Joe Manganiello, nor is he Chris Pine. Is he Christian Bale? No, no. That’s far too American Psycho for our tastes.
I continued my debate with Celebuzz‘s Amanda Hasaka, but we haven’t yet come to a solid agreement on who should play Mr. Grey. I still think that Colin Egglesfield would make a fine dom, but I’d also consider Alex Pettyfer.